The mature minor doctrine, as formally recognized, allows minors to consent to medical treatment without prior permission from a court this aspect of the doctrine is unlike the mature minor rule, articulated by the supreme court (see bellotti v. The mature minor doctrine and the bioethical case law and living wills enunciate the right of the competent adult to make an analysis of competing interests. The american civil liberties union of connecticut filed an amicus brief in the case, supporting the mature minor doctrine and calling for a hearing on whether cassandra is mature enough to make. It's unclear if cassandra's appeal, which will be connecticut's first case calling for the mature-minor doctrine, will face similar judicial impediments.
The mature minor doctrine cassandra's lawyers argued that even though she was not yet 18 years old, and therefore not legally allowed to make medical decisions on her own, under the mature minor doctrine theory she could decide to forgo chemotherapy treatments. Rule of parental consent to the medical treatment of a minor7 under the mature minor doctrine, a minor is allowed to consent or refuse to consent to his medical treatment if it is established that the minor is sufficiently mature to understand, discern and appreciate the benefits and risks of the proposed medical treatment8 1 cobbs v grant, 502 p2d 1, 10 (cal1972. The mature minor doctrine, as established by case law, has not yet not been interpreted as permitting the consent of an adolescent to an intrusive nontherapeutic procedure such as ld hence, with the exception of michigan, parental permission will always be required when ld by a minor is considered.
The so-called mature minor doctrine is based on a seemingly simple principle: minors who demonstrate a sufficient level of maturity ought to have their choices respected independent of third parties. Title = when ethics consultation and courts collide: a case of compelled treatment of a mature minor, abstract = a fourteen year old is diagnosed with aplastic anemia the teen and his parents are jehovah's witnesses. Minor refuses to take his medicine, kicks and screams about it, complains of the side effects, or runs away from home, he can be found to be mature whereas if an adult acted in this same.
Emancipated minor invoke mature minor doctrine for patients 16 years and older based on clinical judgement that minor is able to make informed healthcare decisions for. Pennsylvania does not recognize the mature minor doc- trine as a defense against the manslaughter charges, but the court failed to discuss whether the doctrine gave the. The case summaries below deal with this mature minor doctrine issuereaders interested in the mature minors issue, and its legal arguments, should also read the martin case summary located on our school webpage.
Case study analysis: ethical issues (add student's name) (add tutor's name) (add date) case study analysis: ethical issues 1 the given case study addresses c. Informed consent and assent in clinical pediatrics case summary does recent research on adolescent brain development inform the mature minor doctrine j med. The mature minor doctrine, although it is sometimes controversial, has been successfully applied to teenagers and adolescents who sought to refuse a medical treatment, such as chemotherapy, because of a religious or other personal objection here are five examples of its application 1 ernestine.
Emancipation and the mature minor doctrine there are 3 situations in which a minor, rather than his or her parents, has the legal authority to make decisions regarding his or her health care: emancipation the mature minor exception and exceptions based on specific medical conditions. Connecticut has no law on this issue—no mature minor doctrine—but also no case law neither has the us supreme court ruled on this issue thus, the case could change medical decision-making power for many teens in that state. The right of mature minors in illinois to the minor in that case did not dealing with the mature minor doctrine in the context of constitu.